Our Space

Welcome to a unique coffee experience. What a blend of comfortable space, sustainable coffee and wonderful people. Our refurbished 100+ yr. old building is full of charm and character.

We are a Certified Green Cafe

Come find us!


We pour the finest coffees from around the world. Living up to our motto “Coffee for the Greater Good”, we source only Fair and Ethically Traded, Shade Grown, and Always Organic coffees.

Expand your love of coffee by attending our exclusive cuppings and educational events!

Order your favorite First Ave Coffees Below!

Delivered directly to your door!

First Ave Blend
Origin: Brazil, Ethiopia | various
Process: Pulp-Natural, Natural
Varieties: Various
Tasting Notes: strawberry, cocoa, pear


vegan* gf* keto* everyone else*
Donuts Donuts Keto donuts
Pecan coffee cake
Oatmeal Cookie Cornmeal savory muffin Cheddar / onion biscuit Savory flockette
Rice crispy treat
Cookies Savory Biscuit Sweet flockette
Savory Biscuit Banana and Pumpkin bread
Zuccini humus wrap Brownie affagatto Mixed dried fruit and nuts Apple streusel cake
Grilled cheese w/ pesto Chocolate chip cookie Hardboiled egg Shortbread cookie
Fruit Crumble Muffin Pecan bar Roast beef / cheese / veggie wrap
Scone Turkey / cheese / cranberry / veggie wrap
Oatmeal cookie
Seasonal Cake
Fruit crumble muffin
Yogurt parfait

*Prepared fresh daily in our on-site gf, peanut free bakery Doughlicious and Glorious Breads.

Check our Instagram page for daily availability

Coffee Cocktails

Let us pour a killer round of coffee cocktails (non-alcoholic) for you and your theater companions.  Don’t fall asleep at the show, come and pre-funk with us!


Grand Opening, Grand Success!

After much anticipation, First Ave Coffee is now officially open. A huge thank you to all of our customers and supporters who came in to celebrate.   Friends, family, coffee, music and treats… what else is there!?